Assessment of Approaches for Wireless Authentication
| Approach for Wireless Authentication | ||||
| Mobile Equipment without SIM | Mobile Equipment with WIM | Mobile Equipment with SIM | Mobile Equipment with USIM | |
| Wireless communications standard | All systems | WAP2.0 enabled | GSM, GPRS, EDGE | 3G |
| Number of keys | 1 symmetric | 1 asymmetric pair | 1 symmetric | 2 symmetric, Many asymmetric pairs |
| Key length | n/a* | Variable | 32 bit | 128 bit symmetric, no length limit for asymmetric |
| Key storage | n/a | WIM, USIM | SIM | USIM, WIM |
| Mechanism | RSA challenge via SMS | Wireless Transport Layer Security (WTLS) | Cell phone authentication with shared key | Mutual authentication, PKI |
| Authentication strength | Moderate† | Strong | Weak‡ | Strong |









